What To Do When An Opponent Doesn’t Follow Eligibility Rules
This resource stems from a question submitted to the Ask PCA blog. Responses come from our experts including PCA Trainers, who lead live group workshops for coaches, parents, administrators and student-athletes.
"If you knew a team/school wasn't following eligibility rules, are you obligated to say something? Especially if a player won an event while disregarding these rules?"
PCA Response by PCA Lead Trainer, Joe Terrasi
Thank you for asking an especially difficult question. One of the core tenets of honoring the game is to respect the rules. (We encourages coaches, athletes, parents and fans to honor the ROOTS of the game - the Rules, our Opponents, the Officials, our Teammates, and our Self.) The decision to ensure that others honor these elements can be a difficult.
In this delicate situation, it would be helpful to have a face-to-face conversation with the coach, athletic director, or other organizational leader. Before questioning whether a rule was broken, you should work carefully to understand the exact eligibility rule as well as the school’s interpretation and application of the rule. As a former high school athletic director, I can vouch that eligibility rules can get surprisingly complex. To add to the complexity, many schools choose to apply more stringent criteria than are required by the state athletic association (for example, your state may require a “C” average while the school may choose to require a “B” average to participate in contests). Eligibility rules related to transfers and residence locations can also be complex and confusing.
Download a printable version of this resource, including any additional commentary from PCA, by clicking the PDF below. To read more questions and answers like this, or to submit your own question to the Ask PCA blog, click here.